Discover what others are learning
Curated Torah sources across every topic, from classical texts to contemporary responsa.
Hakafot on Hoshana Rabbah When It Falls on Shabbat
When Hoshana Rabbah occurs on Shabbat, the customary hakafot (circumambulations) around the synagogue with the lulav are not performed. Sources explain this practice through rabbinic concern that handling the lulav on Shabbat might lead to its being carried in the public domain, and note that the aravah was similarly not taken on Shabbat in Temple times.
בשבת אין מקיפים, לפי שגם במקדש לא היו נוטלין ערבה בשבת
Milking Animals on Shabbat for Relief
Sources address whether milking an animal on Shabbat is permitted when done to relieve the animal's suffering rather than to collect milk for human use. The sources establish the principle of tza'ar ba'alei chayim (preventing animal suffering) as a basis for certain Shabbat exceptions, while also distinguishing between actions whose primary purpose is animal relief and those undertaken for human benefit.
צער בעלי חיים