parshaמפרשי הפרשה

רבינו בחיי — ויעתר יצחק לה' לנכח אשתו כי עקרה היא

Why does the pasuk open with Yitzchak's prayer and then mention Rivkah's barrenness — shouldn't it follow chronology, first establishing the barrenness and only then describing the response to it?

הכתוב היה ראוי להקדים ולומר ותהי רבקה עקרה ואח"כ ויעתר יצחק לה' כי עקרה היא, ומה שהקדים התפלה יתכן לומר שהקדים העיקר, ולמדנו שאין הכונה שתהיה העקרות סבת התפלה שא"כ הסבה עיקר והתפלה טפל לה, אבל הכונה לשון הכתוב כי התפלה סבת העקרות, ולומר לך שלא נתעקרה אלא כדי שיתפללו שניהם על הדבר... מפני מה נתעקרו האמהות מפני שהקב"ה מתאוה לתפלתן של צדיקים.

1 source · all verified

Opens as a working sheet — explore, annotate, and export.

Source 1 · Rishonim
Verified

רבינו בחיי

רבנו בחיי, בראשית כ״ה:כ״א

Rabbeinu Bahya, Bereshit 25:21

Q — Why does the pasuk open with Yitzchak's prayer and then mention Rivkah's barrenness — shouldn't it follow chronology, first establishing the barrenness and only then describing the response to it?

A — Rabbeinu Bachya reads the word-order as a chiddush: the tefillah is the עיקר, the barrenness is its טפל. "אין הכונה שתהיה העקרות סבת התפלה שא"כ הסבה עיקר והתפלה טפל לה, אבל הכונה לשון הכתוב כי התפלה סבת העקרות" — the akarut was not the cause of the tefillah; the tefillah was the cause of the akarut. Hashem made Rivkah barren specifically in order to elicit the prayers of the tzaddikim — which is why the same pattern recurs in three of the four Imahot. The chiddush: nature can be re-engineered backwards from tefillah. The world is structured so that the desired prayer of a tzaddik is the underlying cause and the apparent suffering is merely its conduit. The pasuk's syntax encodes this reversal directly.

הכתוב היה ראוי להקדים ולומר ותהי רבקה עקרה ואח"כ ויעתר יצחק לה' כי עקרה היא, ומה שהקדים התפלה יתכן לומר שהקדים העיקר, ולמדנו שאין הכונה שתהיה העקרות סבת התפלה שא"כ הסבה עיקר והתפלה טפל לה, אבל הכונה לשון הכתוב כי התפלה סבת העקרות, ולומר לך שלא נתעקרה אלא כדי שיתפללו שניהם על הדבר... מפני מה נתעקרו האמהות מפני שהקב"ה מתאוה לתפלתן של צדיקים.

Related sheets

Halachaהלכה

Blessings on Bubble Tea With Pearls

Sources address how to apply the halakhic principles of primary and secondary foods (ikkar and tafel) to mixed beverages and edible solids consumed together. The blessing depends on whether the tapioca pearls are considered subordinate to the drink or an independent component requiring their own bracha.

View Sources39 sources
Mussarמוסר

Guarding Speech and Refining Character

These sources explore the profound connection between controlling one's speech and developing moral and spiritual excellence. Drawing from biblical wisdom, rabbinic teaching, and philosophical works, they demonstrate how careful speech reflects inner purity, prevents sin, and serves as a foundation for character refinement.

View Sources30 sources
Halachaהלכה

Bloodstains on Colored Garments and Minimum Size

These sources address the halakhic treatment of bloodstains found on colored clothing, including why colored garments receive leniency in stain assessment and what minimum measure (shiur gris) a stain must reach to create ritual prohibitions. The sources examine both the Torah-based and rabbinically-ordained aspects of these laws.

View Sources27 sources
Shabbatשבת

Shabbat Observance on a Sea Voyage

Sources address the halakhic challenges of traveling by ship near or on Shabbat, including permissibility based on voyage timing and purpose, boundary restrictions, food preparation by non-Jews, and water-related activities. These sources establish the practical framework for assessing whether a cruise itinerary is compatible with Shabbat observance.

View Sources25 sources
Israelארץ ישראל

The Obligation to Ascend to Eretz Yisrael

Sources examine whether Jewish law imposes a binding obligation to settle in the Land of Israel, addressing the obligation's source in Scripture and Rabbinic tradition, its scope and exceptions, and how it applies in different historical periods and personal circumstances.

View Sources25 sources
Machshavaמחשבה

The Binding of Isaac: Spiritual Demands and Lessons

These sources explore the Akeidah as both a historical event and an enduring spiritual teaching, examining what Abraham and Isaac's willingness to undergo the binding demands of believers across generations. They discuss themes of mesirut nefesh (self-sacrifice), fear of God, trust in the divine, and how the binding elevates and consecrates life rather than destroying it.

View Sources23 sources

Explore more