The mizbeach is built of many stones gathered together, while the matzeivah is a single stone set up alone — a contrast drawn explicitly by Rashi (Devarim 12:3-4) and elaborated by the Ramban (Devarim 16:22), who describes the mizbeach as a high structure of stones with four horns and a surrounding base, built specifically for sacrificial service.
Both structures appear together in the era of the Avot and at Sinai as legitimate vehicles of avodas Hashem: Yaakov sets up a matzeivah, pours oil upon it, and vows that it will become a house of God (Bereishit 28:18-22), later returning to pour a drink-offering and oil on that same pillar (Bereishit 35:14-15); and at Sinai, Moshe builds a mizbeach together with twelve matzeivos representing the twelve tribes, and the service of offerings and blood is centered specifically on the mizbeach (Shemot 24:4-8).
Once the Torah is given, the matzeivah — though beloved in the days of the Avot — becomes hated, while the mizbeach remains commanded, as Devarim 16:21-22 forbids erecting a matzeivah beside the altar; Rashi (Devarim 16:22) explains this is because the matzeivah became a fixed statute of the Canaanites for idolatry, and the Ramban (Devarim 16:22) adds that before the giving of the Torah the prohibition against following the nations' practices did not yet apply, so Yaakov could use a matzeivah for the sake of Heaven, whereas afterward it was barred even for legitimate worship of God, since all the idolaters' practices became hated before Him.
Sifrei Devarim 146 frames this shift as a kal vachomer: if the matzeivah, which was beloved to the forefathers, became hated to their descendants, all the more so idolatry itself, which was always hated to the forefathers, must be hated to the descendants.
Mishneh Torah, Foreign Worship and Customs of the Nations 6:6 and Sefer HaChinukh 493 define the forbidden matzeivah as a structure meant for people to gather at — even to worship God — because that gathering-around-a-single-stone was the idolaters' mode of service, and the Torah sought to distance Israel from any resemblance to it, even when the intent is sincere.
Sforno (Devarim 16:21) situates the matzeivah among items that are outwardly appealing yet spiritually harmful, noting that although the matzeivah had been acceptable before the giving of the Torah (citing the twelve pillars of Shemot 24:4-8), its symbolism — the worshipper standing perpetually fixed before it — became problematic once the Torah legislated proper worship through the mizbeach instead.
On the construction side, Devarim 27:1-8 and Shemot 20:21 describe the mizbeach as built of unworked stones or earth, untouched by iron, for offering peace-offerings and rejoicing before God, while Vayikra 17:11 identifies its core function as atonement through the blood placed upon it — the mizbeach is throughout a site of ongoing, repeated, collective service rather than a single static marker.
The Shem MiShmuel draws the symbolic contrast directly: the mizbeach, made of many stones, represents service to God that is not an individual's private act but a collective, structured avodah, whereas the matzeivah, a single stone, represents a more personal or individual mode of relating to God — explaining why Yaakov was first commanded to build a mizbeach and only afterward permitted to set up a matzeivah to fulfill his vow (Shem MiShmuel, Vayishlach 5).
In a similar vein, the Haamek Davar characterizes the mizbeach as suited for prayer, and the matzeivah as suited for thanksgiving or for an outpouring of the spirit (Haamek Davar (Netziv)), while elsewhere he describes the matzeivah as having become actual idolatry in the form of the bimos, with the mizbeach remaining solely a place for offering to God (Haamek Davar (Netziv)).
Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch reads the mizbeach as the earth lifted upward toward Heaven, built by human hands from attached ground rather than a natural stone like the matzeivah, so that consecrated, deliberate human service — not the raw forces of nature that the nations sought to deify — becomes the basis of avodah, which is why the natural objects such as the ashera and the matzeivah were barred from its vicinity (Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch); he further contrasts the mizbeach's dedication under the sole sovereignty of God with the paganizing worship of natural forces (Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch).
Beyond the structures themselves, the sources develop the mizbeach as a model for everyday avodas Hashem after the Temple's destruction: the Gemara teaches that a person's table now atones in place of the mizbeach (Chagigah 27a:2), a principle the Mishnah Berurah applies to one who shares his bread with the poor (Mishnah Berurah 167:30); Rav Kook likewise teaches that one who relieves himself, washes, dons tefillin, reads Shema, and prays is considered as if he built a mizbeach and offered a sacrifice upon it, comparing the fixed service of good character traits to the mizbeach's construction, which requires renewal only at the start, after which it functions steadily (Rav Kook (Ein Aya, Berakhot 2:11)), and he elsewhere likens the mizbeach to the concentrated locus of service compared to the Mishkan as the structure of the world entire (Rav Kook (Ein Aya, Shabbat 10:2)).
Other sources address the mizbeach's role within Temple ritual itself and the ongoing yearning for the Beit HaMikdash: the willow-branches were stood beside the mizbeach during Sukkot with the crying out 'Yofi lecha mizbeach' (Sukkah 45a:2), a practice continued as a remembrance of the Temple according to Chayyei Adam, Shabbat and Festivals 148:19; the Gemara in Zevachim 116a and the Mishnah in Mishnah Zevachim 14:4-8 discuss the history of sacrificial service on the mizbeach before and after the Mishkan and the restriction of the bamot once Jerusalem was reached, with Sfas Emes al HaShas, Zevachim 116a and Keren Orah, Zevachim 116a elaborating on the nature of the offerings brought at the giving of the Torah; and the Midrash Tehillim teaches that one who occupies himself with the laws of the sacrificial service is considered as though the Temple were rebuilt in his days, likening Torah study at night to actual service on the mizbeach (Midrash Tehillim (Shocher Tov)).
Finally, several sources extend the symbolism of the mizbeach to the inner life of avodah: Sefer HaChinukh 95 explains in the name of the Ramban that each part of the sacrificial process on the mizbeach corresponds to a faculty of the person — hands, speech, thought — so that the mizbeach models the totality of a person's service; Shenei Luchot HaBerit, Torah Shebikhtav, Sefer Vayikra, Torah Ohr, Vayikra:4 describes man himself as meant to be an offering brought near to God in his lifetime in the manner of the heavenly mizbeach; Tanya 27 discusses the suppression of the sitra achara as the inner parallel to the service done through the mizbeach; and Mesillat Yesharim 19 frames the fulfillment of mitzvot in full detail as the deed-based component of piety between man and God, the daily discipline that the mizbeach's constancy represents, while Mishneh Torah, The Chosen Temple 1:1, Likkutei Sichos 36, תרומה, and Likkutei Sichos 11, פקודי 3 extend the mitzvah of the Mikdash and its daily service into an enduring, ongoing obligation of personal construction and devotion in every generation.